How to Evaluate Your Job Offer: Calculating Your True Compensation

Receiving a job offer is an exhilarating moment. But before you accept that shiny new salary number, you need to step
back and critically evaluate your job offer as a complete package.

Many job seekers fixate entirely on the base salary and ignore the hidden costs and benefits that dictate their true
take-home pay and quality of life. Failing to analyze the entire compensation package means you might unknowingly
accept a role that pays less per hour or offers significantly worse health coverage than your current job. You must
learn how to calculate your true compensation to negotiate effectively and make the right career move.

Why Base Salary is a Misleading Metric

When you evaluate a job offer, the base salary is the easiest number to understand. However, comparing two offers
purely on base salary is a dangerous game because it ignores the massive financial impact of company benefits and
out-of-pocket expenses.

Imagine Offer A pays $90,000 but requires a 45-minute daily commute and has expensive healthcare premiums. Offer B
pays $85,000 but is fully remote with 100% employer-paid healthcare. Once you run the math, Offer B will likely
yield a higher net income and save you hundreds of hours in the car annually.

You have to look at the Total Target Compensation (TTC), which combines your base pay with expected performance
bonuses, sign-on bonuses, and equity grants.

Calculating the Hidden Costs of Working

To accurately evaluate your job offer, you must subtract the hidden costs associated with taking the role. This is
especially crucial when deciding between a hybrid, fully in-office, or fully remote position.

The Commute Penalty

Commuting is expensive. You must calculate the cost of fuel, public transit passes, tolls, and vehicle wear and tear.
More importantly, you must calculate the value of your time. If you commute ten hours a week, you are working an
extra 500 hours a year unpaid. When you recalculate your hourly rate including those lost hours, the numbers look
very different.

Get the Tool: The Resume Auditor

Streamline your job application process with our powerful
AI-driven Resume Auditor. Analyze, optimize, and beat the ATS with ease!

Get
The Resume Auditor on Etsy

Healthcare and Retirement Contributions

Never accept an offer without asking for the benefits summary document. Review the monthly healthcare premium costs.
If the new company requires you to pay $400 a month for family coverage while your old company covered it
completely, you just took a $4,800 annual pay cut.

Additionally, review the 401k match policy. A company offering a 5% dollar-for-dollar match is giving you free money
that dramatically increases your total compensation over time.

Assessing Equity and Long-Term Incentives

If you are joining a startup or a public tech company, equity is likely a major component of your compensation. When
you evaluate your job offer, you must understand the vesting schedule and the true value of the shares.

Understanding Vesting Schedules

Most equity grants come with a four-year vesting schedule and a one-year “cliff.” This means you earn nothing if you
leave before your first anniversary. Understand that the stock numbers in your offer letter represent potential
value, not guaranteed cash in hand today.

Public vs. Private Equity

Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) at a public company are essentially cash equivalents once they vest. Stock options at a
private startup are highly risky and may end up being worth zero. Treat startup equity as a lottery ticket bonus
rather than guaranteed income when running your financial calculations.

Quality of Life and Intangible Benefits

Not every aspect of a job offer fits neatly into a spreadsheet. Your mental health, career trajectory, and work-life
balance have immense value that must be weighed carefully.

Paid Time Off (PTO) and Flexibility

Assess the PTO policy. Moving from four weeks of vacation down to two weeks is a massive downgrade to your quality of
life. Furthermore, ask about the reality of core hours and flexibility. A role that pays well but demands 60-hour
workweeks and weekend availability will rapidly lead to burnout.

Career Growth Trajectory

Sometimes it is worth accepting a slightly lower total compensation if the role offers unparalleled access to
mentorship, rapid promotion cycles, or experience with cutting-edge technologies. Evaluate your job offer by asking
yourself where this specific role will position you three years from now.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much time should I ask for to evaluate a job offer?

It is standard professional practice to ask for 48 to 72 hours to review an offer. Avoid accepting an offer on the
spot over the phone, as you need time to review the written details and benefits summary carefully.

Should I negotiate if the salary is already good?

Yes. You should almost always negotiate. Companies expect candidates to counteroffer, and the initial offer is rarely
their absolute ceiling. Focus your negotiation on data, market rates, and the value you bring.

What if the base salary is non-negotiable?

If the company cannot budge on base pay, pivot to negotiating other elements. Ask for a sign-on bonus, extra paid
vacation days, enhanced equity grants, or a guaranteed six-month performance review.

How do I verify the company culture before accepting?

During the offer stage, ask to speak with a current team member who wasn’t on your interview panel. Search for the
company on Glassdoor, but filter for recent reviews from your specific department to get a realistic picture.

What is an exploding job offer?

An exploding offer requires you to accept within an unreasonably short timeframe, usually 24 hours. This is a massive
red flag indicating a high-pressure environment. Politely request more time, and reconsider if they refuse.